Older vs. New: What Type of Home Should I Buy?

When you're on the hunt for your dream home, you're bound to face a dilemma: should you go for the classic charm of a mature house or the sleek, modern feel of a new one? 

It all comes down to preference, but a little insider wisdom can help you dodge some unexpected curveballs. Let's take a leisurely stroll through some vital things to consider when choosing between vintage and new.

First off, we'll discuss the perks of a home with a few extra birthdays under its belt.

  • Unique architecture

Homes that are older often boast architectural designs and details that newer properties may lack. These features, like ornate moldings and stained glass windows, provide a sense of history and character. Each of these beauties has a story to tell, and they don't mind sharing.

  • Mature landscaping 

These homes frequently come with well-established gardens and landscaping, including mature trees and shrubs. It can feel like your own personal oasis, offering extra privacy and a backdrop of lush greenery. This is a vital step for making your perfect outdoor living space.

  • Better craftsmanship (sometimes) 

custom bathroom

You'd be surprised to know that some of the older homes out there were built with such precision that they almost put modern technology to shame. Many were constructed with more attention to detail as skilled artisans used traditional building methods to create durable structures. Of course, this can vary depending on when it was built and who was in charge!

  • Lower purchase prices 

This one is part upside, part downside. With mature homes, you can expect a lower price point, but that's because the house has likely earned some battle scars over the years. You might need to jazz up some outdated features and tackle a few repairs. If you’re looking for a lower price in the short term but are willing to put some extra cash into the home for the long haul, an older home may be right up your alley. 

  • Ability to negotiate selling concessions 

As an extra bonus to sweeten the deal and offset these costs, you can negotiate with the seller for concessions. These are financial incentives that can help cover your renovation and repair bills. But you don’t have to do it alone. At Fine Point Homes, we hammer through every detail with our clients to work towards a fair price. 

Now, let's turn the spotlight to the downsides of an older home.

  • Replacing home features that are too old

As we've hinted earlier, you'll likely need to give some tired features a facelift. Elements like the roof and windows can age and deteriorate, leading to leaks, drafts, and more maintenance work than you might care for. 

  • Foundational repairs required 

You may also find a little extra character in the form of foundational issues. These can creep up due to the house settling, shifting soil, or simply the natural wear and tear that comes with age. This potentially means a substantial home makeover project that can be heavy on the wallet.

  • Frequent maintenance 

Don't be surprised if you find yourself juggling regular maintenance tasks to keep things in tip-top shape as these homes seem to have an ongoing need for tender love and care.

  • Bathrooms, kitchen, and appliances may need updating 

The kitchen and bathrooms are the heart of your home. In an older home, these are likely to be fitted with outdated fixtures and appliances. While they may work, they are likely to be lacking in terms of energy efficiency and functionality.

Switching to the other side of the coin, let’s take a look at the pros of buying new.

  • No need for updating 

This one sort of goes without saying. Newer homes are ready to roll the minute you sign the dotted line, so no need to embark on a mission to modernize the place.

  • Energy efficiency 

Custom kitcken

These homes are the eco-warriors of the housing world. Think top-notch insulation, energy-efficient windows, and HVAC systems that can relieve some stress when it comes time to pay the bills. 

  • Less maintenance 

They're also designed with low-maintenance materials and modern technology that's built to last, so you can spend less time tinkering and more time doing what you love.

  • Buyer/builder incentives and concessions 

Builders of newer homes often sweeten the deal with incentives and concessions to lure you in. They might offer financial perks, like covering some of your closing costs or throwing in shiny new appliances to make your life easier. 

Of course, there’s always a catch…

  • Price 

Newer homes come with that fresh, out-of-the-box smell and a price tag to match. The modern features can come at a premium, so brace yourself to splurge a bit more.  

  • Less mature landscaping 

With their younger gardens, newer homes can't always compete with the vintage curb appeal. When you step into a newly built home, don't expect to be greeted by a lush, mature garden right out of the gate.

  • Additional expenses 

They look shiny and modern but often come with unforeseen expenses. Blinds, light fixtures, and other little details that you'd never think about can sneak up on you when you least expect.

  • Higher taxes 

Newer homes, with their added value and modern amenities, often come with higher property taxes. So, while you're enjoying those fancy new features, be ready for the taxman to come knocking for a bigger slice of the pie.

The choice between older and newer homes ultimately hinges on your lifestyle and budget—there's no one-size-fits-all answer. It's a journey where personal taste, needs, and circumstances will guide you to the right front door. Whether you're drawn to the timeless allure of history or the sleek embrace of modernity, consider your options carefully and embark on the path that feels most like home.



Fine Point Homes believes in cutting through the confusion around your perfect home - whether that’s buying new or upgrading your existing house. We simplify the process and stay in touch during every aspect so that you always know what comes next.

If you’re interested in setting up an interview with our Real Estate team, contact us here.

Previous
Previous

How to Avoid the “Hidden Costs” of a Home Remodel

Next
Next

Should I add an outdoor living space to my home?